The city’s own cost figure
Tarpon Springs defines substantial improvement at 50 percent of the structure’s market value, and it sets the cost side of that comparison itself. Construction costs are compared using the most current ICC Valuation, the building valuation data the International Code Council publishes, and the valuation is subject to review and approval by the Building Official.
More on ICC Valuation
For an addition, the figure the city works with is its own valuation of the new square footage at the published rate, not the price in the contract. A wing contracted above or below that rate does not move the city’s number, so the comparison can be run as soon as the floor area and the type of construction are known.
The rest of the packet comes from the owner’s side: an elevation certificate goes in with the substantial improvement and substantial damage packet, and for the house’s value the city accepts only a FEMA 50% Rule actual cash value appraisal. If the city’s figure for the work reaches half that value, the whole building has to meet current floodplain requirements, not only the new rooms.
